The Case for Reading Diverse Literature

REading

This post was on my heart for a while and finally I decided to write it while watching a Harry Potter marathon on television. Give it a read, and tell me what you think.

When I started this blog, I was sure that I’d be one of many– one of hundreds of blogs exploring books written by people of different ethnicity and nationalities. I wasn’t. Moreover, I was one of few blogs that seemed to have an interest in reading much diverse literature at all. In 2016, I see that changing for the better. Its amazing to see challenges that inspire bloggers and others to read books by people of color, and I’m excited to see what books people choose. Even though I focus on multicultural literature, I’ve even seen challenges including different sexual orientations and abilities as well, which is even better.

But it’s bigger than the challenges. The need for wider interest in multicultural literature is crucial for so many reasons. This blog post on HuffPo, for example, gives a good set of reasons advocating for the increase of Latin@ books in classrooms. Having multicultural characters helps engage children of color in reading because they can relate to some of the characters. As a woman of color, I can personally testify to this. For their white counterparts, reading books with characters of color help shape a more realistic worldview.

Furthermore, if reading literature has been proven to improve our ability to empathize, it follows that reading literature set in, or including people of different cultures would improve our ability to empathize with people unlike ourselves.

So what is the best way to read literature with which we don’t directly identify? Here are some meditations I’d like to throw into the ring for consideration. Note that there’s lots of overlap between these items, because they’re all intertwined, in my opinion.

  1. Understand your own culture within the context of the book: If nothing else, the best part of reading diverse literature is increased self-awareness. Coming from a Caribbean family, for example, causes me to more closely evaluate African culture, which has stark similarities. It also allows you to confront your own biases, which takes us to the second point….
  2. Empathize/sympathize and learn, even if you can’t understand or agree: For me, this is the most important, if not the most challenging, part of reading multicultural literature. Reading a book where a character undergoes female genital mutilation, or is held in detention after illegally crossing a border challenges me in ways I’d never have imagined. Many times, I read things that I’ll never understand or experience, but that doesn’t remove the intrinsic value in the book itself.
  3. Keep the ethnocentrism to a minimum: This is a complex oneScreen Shot 2015-12-27 at 9.54.10 PM for me, so pardon me while I fish for the words. There’s a difference between learning and observing another culture critically, and immersing oneself in that culture.  Even I’ve found myself missing the point while reading because I got hung up on judging aspects of a culture I’d only just begun learning about through the lens of my own culture. That’s not to say reading diverse literature requires accepting everything at face value—but when reading, look to immerse instead of judge when appropriate.
  4. Diverse settings and characters are no substitute for diverse authors: This argument has emerged in so many ways. Valentino’s 2015 Paris Fashion Week show was criticized for being heavily influenced by Africa, without having many actual minorities on the runway. The same thing goes for literature: while there are many amazing stories told by people outside of the culture, sometimes its best to let them speak for themselves. Sometimes, being a cultural visitor is a vital element to the story. But it’s not enough to riddle your bookshelf with books about strangers in a strange land. Your view of other cultures will be narrow if you don’t also have books written by people of those cultures.

So that’s just my two cents. Feel free to expound upon these, or comment with other ones you’d like to add! What are some of your favorite books by people of color?

Advertisements

11 Comments

  1. […] Source: The Case for Reading Diverse Literature […]

    Like

  2. […] Brown Books & Green Tea, a new blog I just discovered thanks to Akilah, has a thought-provoking post making The Case for Reading Diverse Books. […]

    Like

  3. […] Source: The Case for Reading Diverse Literature […]

    Like

  4. cforbes15

    Beautiful post! Thank you for this. I’m taking on the Diversity On The Shelf challenge for 2016, so your words of advice will be super helpful.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks so much! And good luck!

      Like

  5. Your fourth point is soooooo important! I keep telling my friends how important diverse AUTHORS are because they are just as marginalized in real life as diverse protagonists. It’s crucial that we support authors of color.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Great post. I am also not shocked that you haven’t found more blogs that focus on multicultural literature, but I have seen a growing awareness of the need and more bloggers being intentional in mentioning the books they read that feature diversity.

    Like

  7. Well said! I’ve always felt some of these are arguments for reading in general, but they are even stronger for reading multicultural literature. Some books I really enjoyed this year are Americanah, The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, The Book of Unknown Americans, and Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe.

    Like

    1. Yes! These arguments work for all kinds of books, especially from other time periods.

      Liked by 1 person

  8. I hate to say it but to be totally honest I’m not surprised that you weren’t able to find as many people that focus on multicultural literature. It’s almost like the thought of minority representation is a foreign concept which makes no sense because it’s not like we just appeared out of the blue. Despite the fact that it’s overdue, I do think that more people are now starting to seek out diversity in their books though, especially for children. It took awhile, but it’s a start

    Like

    1. Its definitely a start! And I’m so excited for these children’s books that I’ve been seeing. Its amazing, because representation matters– I wish I’d had some of these things growing up, and I wasn’t even in school that long ago.

      Like

Have something to say? Put it here!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s